Ghost

Ghost private site mode: the access switch

Private site mode switches off every SEO feature sitewide, while members-only posts stay indexable as URLs. Where each switch lives, what each one costs.

Ghost private site mode switches off all search engine optimization features sitewide behind one shared password. Turn it off in Settings > Membership > Access if the site should be public, then check a post URL. Members-only posts behave differently: the URL stays indexable, the protected content does not.

Why Ghost does this

Ghost's own setup guide: "you can use private site mode with a shared password, by enabling this option from the Settings > Membership > Access area. When private site mode is on, all search engine optimization features are switched off to keep your site under the radar." That is a sitewide kill switch, not a page setting, and Ghost warns "This is not secure authentication," so it is a privacy curtain that stays on far longer than intended. The second mechanism is different in kind: Ghost's protected content FAQ says "URLs with protected content are available to be indexed by the search engines, but protected content on that URL can't be accessed or crawled," and "All posts and pages published on your Ghost site are automatically included in an XML sitemap, regardless of the content access level." Members-only posts therefore surface in search with title and excerpt and no body, which is a content decision, not an accident to fix.

Check it right now

Before changing anything, confirm what a crawler actually sees. The check is free, takes one URL and needs no account.

Run the check

How to fix it

  1. Open Settings > Membership > Access in the Ghost admin.
  2. Disable "Private site" (private site mode) if the publication should be publicly visible.
  3. Save, then open a post URL in a private browser window and confirm it loads without the password gate.
  4. Run the indexability checker on a key post URL and confirm robots meta data no longer blocks indexing.
  5. For members-only posts appearing in search with no content: this is documented Ghost behavior, not a fault. Keep a public preview section above the paywall divider if you want those URLs to earn their place, or unpublish posts that should not be listed.
  6. Resubmit the sitemap in Search Console if the site was private for a long stretch.

Why it happens again

Private site mode is the onboarding default for a publication built before it had an audience, and it has no expiry. A newsletter that shipped private during setup keeps SEO features off until someone opens Settings > Membership > Access, which is a different menu from the content work, and nothing on the site itself indicates it.

stillindexed re-checks the URLs you give it every 30 minutes on Starter and alerts when a directive changes, at most 30 minutes after it does. It is a monitor rather than a crawler: it watches a list you choose and tells you when one of seven things changes. Start with a 30-day free trial, 3 sites, no card required, and a 30 day refund after that.

Start the 30-day free trial, 3 sites, no card required

Catching it next time

Fixing it once is the easy half. The setting that caused this can be changed again by anyone with access, and the page will keep returning 200 while it happens.

A noindex tag hiding the site from search, on other platforms

How Search Console reports it

Sources

Every claim about Ghost above is from their own documentation, read on 2026-10-25. Platforms change their settings; if one of these is out of date, their page wins and we would like to know.