Stillindexed vs NoindexWatch

Both watch a list of your URLs for noindex, robots.txt, canonical and redirect changes and email you when one flips. NoindexWatch is cheaper at every tier: $19 a month for 10 sites checked hourly against our $39 for 15 sites checked every 30 minutes. Stillindexed is built for SEO consultants and small agencies who want the alert within 15 to 30 minutes of a deploy, on Telegram as well as email, with white-label client reports on Agency. Both have a free plan for one site; theirs watches up to 20 URLs on it, ours watches 1.

We make one of these two. Every NoindexWatch fact below was read from noindexwatch.com on 2026-11-02. Where their site does not mention something, the table says "not described" rather than "no".

What's the difference between Stillindexed and NoindexWatch?

NoindexWatchStillindexed
Free plan1 site, up to 20 URLs, daily, no card1 site, 1 URL daily, robots.txt every hour, no card, no end date; new accounts start on a 30-day trial with 3 sites
Check frequencydaily on Free, hourly on paid planseach URL every 30 min on Starter, 15 on Agency, daily on Free; robots.txt every hour on every plan
Sites per plan1 / 10 / 40 / 150, up to 20 URLs each1 / 15 / 50, up to 25 URLs each on paid plans; 10 on Founding Lifetime
Price per month$0 / $19 / $49 / $99$0 / $39 / $79; or $349 once (10 founding seats)
Alertsemail, Slack or Discord, on every plan including Freeemail on every plan; Telegram and Slack on paid plans and the trial; no Discord
Meta robots noindexyes (robots, googlebot, bingbot)yes
X-Robots-Tag headeryes, on the page and every redirect hopyes
robots.txtwith each URL check, for Googlebot and Bingbotread every hour, evaluated per monitored path for Googlebot and the * group, re-read 5 minutes later before it alerts
Canonicaltag or Link header pointing elsewhereyes
Sitemapa monitored URL no longer listedread every 24 hours: unreachable, malformed, or more than half its URLs gone
SSL and domain expirynot describedcertificate every 24 hours, domain expiry every 7 days
Client reports (white-label)not describedweekly report on Starter; white-label, one per client, on Agency
WordPress pluginnot describedfree plugin, zip download on the WordPress page
MCP servernot describedHTTP MCP endpoint for the free checkers, no account
Research and dataguides to Search Console statusespublished studies with the data, such as 106 of 9,078 reachable .gov homepages telling search engines to stay out (22 October 2026), plus guides to Search Console statuses
Free one-off tools12, no signup16, no account

NoindexWatch columns from noindexwatch.com and noindexwatch.com/bot, read 2026-11-02. Their site lists prices "in USD per month, as of October 2026". Capterra and GetApp, read the same day, list the same four plans but put Agency at $98.88 a month; we use the $99 on NoindexWatch's own site.

Which is cheaper for 1, 10 and 40 sites?

NoindexWatch, at every size. Here are both price lists side by side, with the arithmetic.

SitesNoindexWatchStillindexed
1Free: up to 20 URLs, dailyFree: 1 URL daily, robots.txt every hour. More URLs on one site means Starter, $39
10$19 Starter, $1.90 a site, hourly$39 Starter (15 sites), $3.90 a site at 10, every 30 min
40$49 Pro, $1.23 a site, hourly$79 Agency (50 sites), $1.98 a site at 40, every 15 min
150$99 Agency, $0.66 a site, hourlyno plan; our largest is 50 sites

Per URL the gap is smaller. Their Starter is $0.095 a URL at 200 URLs, ours $0.104 at 375. Their Pro is $0.061 at 800, our Agency $0.063 at 1,250. What the extra money buys on our side is cadence: each URL is checked 2 times an hour on Starter and 4 on Agency, against once an hour.

One case where we cost less over time: Founding Lifetime is $349 once for 10 sites at 30 minutes. After 19 months, NoindexWatch Starter for the same 10 sites has cost $361, more than the lifetime price. It is capped at 10 seats in total.

Which catches a bad deploy faster?

On paid plans, the one that checks more often. NoindexWatch's paid plans check each URL once an hour, so a noindex that ships right after a check waits up to an hour. Ours waits up to 30 minutes on Starter and 15 on Agency. A new critical change is re-checked after 60 seconds before it alerts, so a change that reverts inside that minute does not page you. On both free plans a URL is checked once a day.

robots.txt is different. NoindexWatch reads it with each URL check, so daily on its free plan. We read it every hour on every plan, the free one included, and re-read a new block 5 minutes later before alerting. A Disallow: / pushed from staging is the one change that can take a whole site out at once, which is why it gets the faster schedule.

Where the alert lands matters as much as when. NoindexWatch sends email, and Slack or Discord through a webhook, on every plan. We send email on every plan, and Telegram and Slack on paid plans and the trial. If your team lives in Discord, they have it and we do not.

Which is better for agencies?

It depends on how many sites, and on what the client sees. Past 50 sites, NoindexWatch is the only one of the two with a plan: its Agency plan covers 150 sites, 3 times our largest, for $99 with hourly checks.

If you bill clients for monitoring, our Agency plan sends each client a white-label weekly report that shows how many checks ran and how many pages loaded, with no mention of us. That is the document that proves the watching happened. NoindexWatch's site does not describe client reports. Change history runs 90 days on Starter and 365 on Agency; theirs is not described.

When should you pick NoindexWatch instead?

  • Price per site decides it. $19 for 10 sites and $99 for 150 are cheaper than anything we sell, at every tier.
  • You watch more than 50 sites. Their Agency plan goes to 150. Ours stops at 50.
  • You want more on a free plan. Up to 20 URLs on one site, with Slack or Discord alerts. Ours is 1 URL with email.
  • Your alerts go to Discord. We do not send to Discord.
  • You care about Bingbot rules or sitemap membership per URL. They evaluate robots.txt for Bingbot by name and flag a monitored URL that drops out of the sitemap. We evaluate Googlebot and the * group, and watch the sitemap as a whole.
  • An hourly check is fast enough. For a brochure site or a blog that deploys once a week, it usually is.

When Stillindexed is the better fit

  • You need the alert inside 30 minutes. Every 30 minutes on Starter, 15 on Agency, with a 60-second confirmation.
  • You want robots.txt watched every hour even on the free plan.
  • You report to clients. White-label weekly reports on Agency.
  • You want Telegram, or TLS and domain expiry in the same monitor.
  • You want a refund or a one-off price. 30 days, unconditional, on paid plans, and $349 once while the 10 founding seats last.

How to switch from NoindexWatch

  1. Copy the URLs you watch there, one site at a time. Up to 20 per site fits inside our 25 on paid plans.
  2. Add the site in Stillindexed and paste the list. Full URLs, bare paths and a column copied from a spreadsheet all work; a line that belongs to another domain is rejected with the reason, not dropped.
  3. Add Telegram or a Slack webhook to the site and send a test alert. It reports back per channel, so a webhook that receives nothing shows up now rather than on the day it matters.
  4. Run both for a week. The first check on each URL is judged on its own, so a page already carrying noindex is reported at once.

Questions

Is there a free noindex monitor?
Yes, both of these. NoindexWatch's free plan watches 1 site with up to 20 URLs, checked daily, with alerts by email, Slack or Discord and no card. Stillindexed's free plan watches 1 site with 1 monitored URL checked once a day, with email alerts and 7 days of change history, no card and no end date; robots.txt for that site is still read every hour. New accounts start on a 30-day free trial, 3 sites, no card required. Google Search Console is free too, but it reports a noindex after Google has recrawled the page, not when it ships.
Does NoindexWatch check robots.txt and canonicals?
Yes. Its site says each monitored URL is fetched with its robots.txt, flags a new Disallow that blocks Googlebot or Bingbot using Google's longest-match rules, and flags a canonical tag or Link header that starts pointing to another URL. It also reads the X-Robots-Tag header on the page and on every redirect hop, status codes and redirect chains, whether the URL is still listed in the XML sitemap, and which of 14 AI crawlers robots.txt blocks.
Can I monitor client sites under my agency brand?
With Stillindexed, yes: Agency ($79 a month, 50 sites) sends a white-label weekly report for each client, with no mention of us, showing how many checks ran and how many loaded. NoindexWatch's site, read on 2026-11-02, does not describe client reports or white-labelling. Its alerts are one email per run, grouped by site, plus Slack or Discord if you add a webhook.
How much does NoindexWatch cost?
Read from noindexwatch.com on 2026-11-02: Free $0 (1 site, up to 20 URLs, daily), Starter $19 a month (10 sites, hourly), Pro $49 (40 sites, hourly) and Agency $99 (150 sites, hourly), up to 20 URLs per site on every plan. Capterra and GetApp list the same plans but put Agency at $98.88; we use the figure on NoindexWatch's own site.

Try it on one page first

Run the noindex checker on the page you would least like to lose. If you want it watched, the free noindex monitor covers one site with no card, or see pricing for more. For the wider field, see Little Warden compared, Conductor (ContentKing) compared and every SEO monitoring tool compared.

Start the 30-day free trial, 3 sites, no card required

Other comparisons: little warden · contentking · screaming frog · lumar · semrush · sitebulb · change monitors · search console · ahrefs · deltio · janitor · seotesting · pagecrawl · sitechecker · seobility · seoradar

Check it yourself before believing any of this

We make one of the products being compared, so the useful thing we can offer is not another claim. These run one check against any URL, free, with no account and no email.

If a result surprises you on a client site, that is the thing this category exists to catch. Six checks when a site disappears from Google walks the same ground by hand.